I remember Wizard Magazine did an article on this particular match up, except it was ALL of the Flash's rogues versus ALL of Spider-Man's villains....and Wizard decided DC would've won it.
That's why I'm doing this my way, and pitting the definitive versions of both of villain teams against each other in a fight to the death. That's right a fight to the death.
I know the Rogues have their own code when it comes to killing, as far as they only do it when they absolutely have to, and when it's out of vengeance/revenge.
I also know the Sinister Six, any variation of the Sinister Six, is more lax about killing, and usually go for the kill against whoever it is they're after, ESPECIALLY Spider-Man.
So, that being said, I'm going to make things easy on myself and only use original members only.
Here's how they stack up:
-The (original) Sinister Six:
1). Doctor Octopus
|Abilities||(As Doctor Octopus/Superior Octopus):|
2). The Vulture
|Abilities||Genius electrical engineer|
Electromagnetic tailored body-harness grants:
Enhanced physical attributes
|Abilities||Size and mass manipulation|
Earth manipulation Superhuman strength, durability and endurance
Flight (in sandstorm form)
5). Kraven the Hunter
1). Captain Cold
|Abilities||Master tactician, Master Thief and strategist|
Extensive knowledge of cryonics
Possesses a 'cold gun' that allows him to freeze objects to absolute zero temperatures
2). Mirror Master
|Abilities||Various powers over mirrors, including the ability to travel through them and trap others within them.|
|Abilities||Possesses a handgun sized flamethrower and knowledge of pyrotechnics and combustibles|
Wears an asbestos suit that protects him from fire and heat
Pipe attached to his left arm that allows him to put out fires
4). Captain Boomerang
5). Weather Wizard
|Abilities||Weather manipulation via weather wand|
Limited magnetic manipulation
6). The Trickster
Skilled acrobat and con-artist
Gadgets that give him the ability to perform amazing tricks like walking on air
Now of course I had to leave some members of the Rogues out of this to make it a fair fight, otherwise, The Pied Piper and The Top would be in this as well.
But again, for the sake of fairness, I chose to keep it a strictly 6-on-6 fight to the finish with no advantages in the numbers' department.
And there it is.
A fight to the bitter end between two very famous/infamous teams of supervillains, battling it out for bragging rights.
The Sinister Six
Let me know who you think are the last rogues standing after all's said and done.